If you are like me, you may have been researching different types of tents recently and have noticed that “instant” or pop-up tents are becoming more popular. I also wondered if instant tents were better than regular tents.
It’s entirely up to you what kind of tent you want at the end of the day. Pop-up tents and instant tents are easy to put up and easy to roll up. They are durable, but they are also more expensive. Despite taking more time to set up, regular tents are usually cheaper, pack up smaller, and are more durable if correctly set up.
Instant Tent Pros and Cons
A pop-up tent or instant tent has all its supports attached to its body material, so it is easy to set up. You can twist these tents in a certain way, and they will pop right up. When you’re ready to tear it down, simply reverse what you did when you set it up.
It is shown below that I used an instant tent from Coleman, one of the leading manufacturers of instant tents. I found it to be super easy to setup on a camping trip.
Pros for Instant Tents
- Setting up and tearing down are easy.
- There’s still plenty of room for growth.
- Tent material is equal to that used in regular tents.
Cons for Instant Tents
- The cost is higher.
- You won’t be able to condense down as much.
- There is a greater difficulty in replacing damaged parts.
- Wind tends to make things fold more.
Also like this:
Regular Tent Pros and Cons
This tent is considered to be a “regular” tent because it needs multiple steps to set up. Let’s compare it to another Coleman dome tent that is most similar to the instant tent.
There are several advantages and disadvantages to using a Coleman dome tent, one of the most common tents used in U.S. campgrounds. It is similar in size to a regular setup tent but has some advantages over regular setup tents.
Pros for Regular Tents
- An affordable alternative.
- Folds up into a small space.
- When a part breaks, it is easy to replace it with another.
- A durable windbreaker (depending on the construction and brand).
Cons for Regular Tents
- More effort should be put into setting up and taking down.
- Human error is more likely to occur when setting up.
- An incorrect setup leads to poor stability.
Head To Head Instant Tent Vs Regular Tent
A comparison between an instant tent and a regular tent has been derived by testing dozens of tents on each side and drawing conclusions from the results. To make comparisons easier, here is a list. Keep in mind that all conclusions are based on general trends, but exceptions are always present.
Can instant or pop-up tents be set up quickly?
In addition to instant tents, also known as instant shelters, there are three main types: domes, cabins, and cubes. Both dome and cabin tents share the same shape, while cabin tents have a boxier shape.
In addition to tents with bendable poles, cube tents also can be set up instantly. Their shape is boxy and their frame is made up of bendable poles. The poles twist together to compact into a small size, and setting them up is very simple because all you have to do is toss them in the air, and they stand up by themselves.
Which brands of instant tents can I trust?
Because instant tents are so new, Coleman and Quechua are currently dominating the market. Only Coleman makes instant pop-up tents of this type. There are some interesting tent shapes and bendable poles used in Quechua tents, so these tents are unique in many ways.
Instant tents are usually made of what material?
Due to its durability and foldability, specialized polyester is used to create instant tents, unlike regular tents, which are constructed from many different materials, such as polyester, canvas, PVC, and cuben fiber.
Also like this:
Final Thoughts
The instant vs regular tent comparison was a helpful comparison. Both are fine for different purposes, and both are acceptable in most situations.
Instant tents are ideal for those who do not camp frequently or have a family that requires attention (cough, cough, toddlers…) and want to get started right away. Despite the fact that it costs more, you can set it up quickly and start camping immediately. If you are going to camp with family, it shouldn’t matter if it’s heavier or lighter.
For backpackers and campers who are serious about their camping, regular tents are the best choice. In addition to being easier to carry, it’s also more convenient when you’re on the trail. This route will save you money as well as make it easier for you to travel. We hope this information has helped you make an informed choice, regardless of what you decide.
